A Couple of Points

I wonder who else caught the fact that when Amy in “Amy’s Choice” asks the Doctor (something like) “If you can’t save everyone, then what is the point of you?” this is a direct echo of the Eccleston episode “Dalek” when the Doctor asks the captured Dalek, “If you can’t kill, then what are you good for, what is the point of you?”

18 Responses to A Couple of Points

  1. Black Bloke June 23, 2010 at 9:50 am #

    Didn’t catch it. But I thought it was a hint at theodicy, and a sharp reminder that the Doctor was unable to even save his own family and his own world.

    • Roderick June 23, 2010 at 3:18 pm #

      Seems a bit unfair — he never claimed to be God.

      The relevant quote from “Dalek” occurs around 8:22 here.

      • Roderick June 23, 2010 at 3:20 pm #

        There is of course a great parody of that scene here.

      • Black Bloke June 23, 2010 at 9:44 pm #

        Don’t you recall him as “the lonely god”?

        • Roderick June 23, 2010 at 10:47 pm #

          But “god” as a common noun doesn’t imply omnipotence. Hestia and Hephaestus and Balder are gods, much good it ever did them.

        • Black Bloke June 23, 2010 at 10:59 pm #

          His mastery of time and space would seem to imply a limited omnipotence, but moreover I never said that he was God (and so the theodicy would apply to him), I just heard a “hint” of it.

        • MBH June 24, 2010 at 7:09 pm #

          His mastery of time and space…

          I don’t know about space. Seems that the “Lord of Dreams” character would be the master of space.

        • Black Bloke June 24, 2010 at 8:54 pm #

          I don’t recall distance ever being an issue for the Doctor.

        • MBH June 24, 2010 at 9:37 pm #

          Well, the Lord of Dreams could morph the form of space — more than simply one’s location in space.

        • Roderick June 25, 2010 at 12:36 pm #

          Weren’t the Dream Lord’s creations all illusions?

        • MBH June 25, 2010 at 2:41 pm #

          Wasn’t the tardis moving towards the frozen star real?

        • MBH June 25, 2010 at 5:49 pm #

          Oops. You’re right. Dream Lord created both worlds. Though I think that still counts him as more of a space-master (considering David Lewis’ sense of possible worlds as material and Hillary Putnam’s sense of collective hallucination as indistinguishable from “this” world).

        • Roderick June 25, 2010 at 6:31 pm #

          Even if I agreed with Lewis’s theory (which Athena forfend), it wouldn’t allow travel from one to another.

        • MBH June 25, 2010 at 7:32 pm #

          I don’t agree with Lewis either.

          What is Athena forfend?

          Let me refine the claim. If it’s the case that a collective hallucination is indistinguishable from “this” conventional world, then to open representational space is indistinguishable from morphing the fabric of space. Hence, Dream Lord is more of a space-master than the Doctor. But not nearly as cool.

  2. Roderick June 25, 2010 at 7:57 pm #

    What is Athena forfend?

    Well, “Athena” is a noun, and “forfend” is a verb, so your question is grammatically ill-formed.

    If it’s the case that a collective hallucination is indistinguishable from “this” conventional world, then to open representational space is indistinguishable from morphing the fabric of space. Hence, Dream Lord is more of a space-master than the Doctor.

    Aren’t you trying to derive a metaphysical conclusion from an epistemological premise? Or are you assuming the identity of indiscernibles?

    • MBH June 25, 2010 at 8:46 pm #

      Oops. What does “Athena forfend” mean?

      Oops. I’m smuggling in some metaphysics; Putnam isn’t.

      • Roderick June 25, 2010 at 9:18 pm #

        What does “Athena forfend” mean?

        It’s like “God forbid.” I got it from Theophrastus.

        I’m smuggling in some metaphysics

        Sorry, you have to pay tariffs on that stuff.

        • MBH June 25, 2010 at 10:13 pm #

          Rightfully so. 🙂

Leave a Reply to Black Bloke Click here to cancel reply.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes