20 responses to “Mukti!”

  1. Soviet Onion

    Firefox 3.0.11.NETCLR3.5.30729 Windows XP

    But Roderick, what if some some Hindu/Muslim/Buddhist/Jain fundamentalists wanted to secede from the Imperial Indian state and go there own way? Should they not be supported? How can we know that there’s something wrong with the criminalization of homosexuals?

    It really says something about the priorities ALLies have these days when the rights of “freaky-deaky” sexual minorities matter more than the cause of pan-secessionism against the now plainly totalitarian humanist Indian state!!!

    1. Danny Shahar

      Firefox 3.0.11.NETCLR3.5.30729 Windows Vista

      I’d anticipate that Dr. Long would want to peg this under the “thick libertarian” argument…

      1. Micha Ghertner

        Chrome 2.0.172.33 Windows Vista

        Please, let’s leave the pegging out of this discussion.

  2. Darian

    Firefox 3.0.11 Windows XP

    will return to this thread tomorrow with figurative popcorn

  3. Brandon

    Firefox 9.04jauntyShiretoko Linux

    Obviously India no longer cares about the children.

    Won’t somebody please think of the children?

  4. Darian

    Firefox 3.0.11 Windows XP

    Oh crap! I just realized that this means us homosexualists are on the side of the state! We must side with “the people” if we find a poll that shows a majority of Indians want homosexuality illegal! Now let me find out where the ruling class stands on chopping off the hands of pickpockets, so we know what our position on that issue must be. ;)

  5. Life, Love, and Liberty

    Firefox 3.0.11.NETCLR3.5.30729 Windows Vista

    Roderick “Screaming Sexualist” Long? Might be time for a name change

    ( :

    1. b-psycho

      Firefox 3.0.11.NETCLR3.5.30729 Windows Vista

      I was waiting for someone to note that Dr. Long has been…endowed with a perfect porn name.

      1. Aster

        Firefox 3.0.11 MacIntosh

        ‘Sexualism’ sounds like a great name for an avant-garde arts movement.

        ‘Screaming sexualist’ sounds like a cocktail drink or a designer drug. May I please have another one?

        BTW, my thanks to Roderick for keeping an eye on this sort of thing. Keith really goes to town in the comments section… I must congratulate him for some of the most creative bigotry I’ve ever encountered. I’d protest or something, but it took me at least six minutes to stop laughing. Shall we debate the merits of transspecies equality and the intergenerational love movement? Does the Mofo Alliance deserve our solidarity and support? I’m concerned their cultural politics might be incompatible with left-libertarianism; they’re reputed to be badasses.

        Oh, and you people all have filthy minds. For shame. Poor Roderick. :(

        1. Dennis

          Firefox 3.0.11 Windows XP

          As long as they have mountain-man beards and dress in black t shirts (usually with jeans) the Mofo Alliance is welcome in Left Libertarian circles. I kid, I kid. Oh, and the Screaming Sexualists are a really awesome roller derby team in Salina, Kansas.

  6. Gene

    Firefox 3.0.11 Windows XP

    Rod Long…

    1. Brandon

      Firefox 9.04jauntyShiretoko Linux

      Longrod

  7. Marja Erwin

    Safari MacIntosh

    I feel the need to address some of Keith’s comments on the other blog.

    “Or, let’s say that in the context of a revolutionary coalition there included militant animal rights groups whose membership included “transspecies” persons, some of whom would “self-identify” as a dog, put on collars and run up the street barking.”

    This canard circulates in both trans-hating and trans-ignorant circles. I would normally attribute this to ignorance, but given the past disputes, ignorance, hatred, or some combination all seem like possibilities.

    The simple answer is that two human brains are virtually identical. One human and one non-human brain are very different. There are minor differences in the hypothalamus; the BSTc is thought to be involved in body-mapping and other tissues are thought to be involved in hormone regulation. (None of these are involved in gender roles.)

    The best studies to date show typically-female structures in the brains of trans womyn (assigned male at birth). http://jcem.endojournals.org/cgi/content/full/85/5/2034

    Different hormone levels account for most of the differences between male and female fetuses, and it has been suggested that prenatal variations in the fetus’s or the mother’s hormone production might affect the differentiation of the brain at critical moments.

    There is no known mechanism to explain why a human fetus would have a canine, or any other non-human brain. Other species have diverged from humanity, and each species has gained and lost various developmental pathways. Each species has distinct developmental pathways. Both sexes of any one species, however, share the same pathways.

  8. Anon73

    Firefox 3.0.11 Windows XP

    At any rate Keith suffers from a slight lack of prescience; the internet has already produced such individuals:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Furries#Role_playing

    A picture of a guy in a dog suit holding an anarchist flag would be best to go with this topic but I couldn’t find any.

    1. Marja Erwin

      Safari MacIntosh

      I doubt it.

      I’m not familiar with either furry or cross-dresser communities, but from what I’ve read, furries and cross-dressers seem to have far more in common with each other than with transsexual people.

  9. socialprincipal

    Firefox 3.0.11 Windows Vista

    If furries or ‘trans-species persons’ were regularly harassed, excluded, attacked and killed for how they identify–as transfolks often are–then yes, I would stand with them too.